Old fashioned sugar cookies with sparkling sugar, split open on a plate.

Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies

4.2/5 - (292 votes)

Carol’s Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies have an intense buttery texture with hints of crunchy sugar that will drastically change the way you think about sugar cookies. These giant old fashioned sugar cookie delights are anything but basic!


Unbleached Wheat Flour, Pure Cane Sugar, Brown Sugar*, Butter, Eggs, Salt, Baking Soda, Vanilla, Natural Coarse Crystal Sugar

Allergen Information: CONTAINS WHEAT, MILK AND EGG.


Care & Storage

Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies Cookies stay fresh for 5 days.

  • Freeze cookies in a bag unless you’ll eat them within 48 hours.
  • Don’t store them in a cooler or refrigerator, that will dry them out.
  • To defrost, simply leave them out for 2 hours. Cookies can be refrozen twice.

Follow our tips to keep your cookies as fresh as can be.