Our gourmet cookie flavors

Over 40 years ago, Carol started baking her handmade, gourmet cookies in her kitchen for friends and family. Today, she’s still baking away, but in a state-of-the-art commercial bakery with help from her dedicated staff. Her gourmet cookies are made by hand with premium, all natural ingredients – free of any preservatives or artificial additives.

We’ve added new cookie flavors over the years, but still make them all by hand in small batches. We recommend trying every gourmet cookie flavor to find your favorite. Browse all of our handmade cookie flavors below – available for online ordering and nationwide delivery!

Order Cookies
Browse by cookie flavor:
A chocolate chip cookie on a plate temptingly parted to showcase its gooey inside.

Chocolate Chip Cookies

4/5 - (1307 votes)

The classic. A crisp outside, with a chewy, buttery inside full of rich semi-sweet chocolate chips.

Learn more
A pair of handmade toffee chocolate crunch cookies on a plate, showcasing its chunks.

Toffee Chocolate Crunch

4.5/5 - (771 votes)

Ultra rich dark chocolate chips with sinful toffee bits mixed into our classic, buttery dough.

Learn more
Oatmeal raisin cookies with pecans, split open on a plate.

Oatmeal Raisin Pecan Cookies

3.1/5 - (479 votes)

There’s nothing more nostalgic than our oatmeal raisin cookies with crunchy pecans. Perfectly chunky texture pushes this decadent treat over the top. One of Carol’s classics!

Learn more
Old fashioned sugar cookies with sparkling sugar, split open on a plate.

Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies

4.2/5 - (292 votes)

No homemade sugar cookies can rival the size, texture and taste of our giant handmade version.

Learn more
A pair of peanut butter chocolate cookies on a plate revealing chocolate and peanut butter layers.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Combo Cookies

4.5/5 - (222 votes)

We thought peanut butter cookies couldn’t get any better, then we added chocolate dough. And chocolate chips to top off this perfect cookie combination.

Learn more
A pair of handmade gourmet snickerdoodle cookies, with a sugary crust, resting on a plate.

Snickerdoodle Cookies

4/5 - (277 votes)

Crunchy, cinnamony, chewy snickerdoodle cookies will remind you of fresh apple pie — hold the apple — with extra sugar on top!

Learn more
A scrumptious Kitchen Sink cookie, loaded with nuts, chocolates, and oats.

Kitchen Sink Cookies

2.4/5 - (3025 votes)

When you can’t decide, go with the cookie that has everything but the kitchen sink: nuts, chocolates, oats, coconut, and more.

Learn more
Chocolate chip walnut cookies on a plate, freshly split to entice.

Chocolate Chip Cookies with Walnuts

3.9/5 - (178 votes)

Go crazy. Go wild. Go Chocolate Chip Cookies with nuts. Our classic chocolate chip cookie with extra crunch from California walnuts.

Learn more
Oatmeal chocolate cherry cookies on a plate, rich and tempting.

Oatmeal Chocolate Cherry Cookies

3.4/5 - (183 votes)

Dark chocolate. Cherry. Oatmeal. Cookies. Four things that are not normally together in a cookie but really should be.

Learn more
Decadent double chocolate brownie cookies on a plate.

Double Chocolate Brownie Cookies

3.8/5 - (132 votes)

We took our chocolate dough, added more chocolate, and made a masterpiece of a brownie-like cookie. Get the milk ready.

Learn more
Milk chocolate chunk cookie, a classic indulgence.

Milk Chocolate Chunk Cookies

4.6/5 - (324 votes)

This extreme twist on a classic mixes the biggest cookie with the biggest chunks of milk chocolate.

Learn more
Gooey white chocolate macadamia cookies temptingly split to unveil rich chunks, ready for a treat.

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

4.2/5 - (101 votes)

We put coconut, white chocolate and macadamia nuts in our cookie to transport you to cookie paradise. Hula skirt not included.

Learn more
Two toffee fudge brownie cookies, one broken to reveal gooey inside, on a plate.

Toffee Fudge Brownie Cookies

3.8/5 - (128 votes)

This caramelly, fudge-filled cookie was created when we combined our other incredible chocolate cookies. It lives up to the legacy.

Learn more
Colorful candy M&M cookies on a rainbow bed of coated chocolates.

Candy Cookies

3.8/5 - (162 votes)

Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, with precious candy gems to add flavor and a little crunch.

Learn more
Plant-based chocolate chip cookies atop a bed of chocolate chips.

Plant-Based Chocolate Chip Cookies

3.7/5 - (263 votes)

Our classic chocolate chip cookie without dairy and eggs, but with all the same flavor and deliciousness.

Learn more
Close-up of plant-based sugar cookies sprinkled with large sugar crystals, split in half.

Plant-Based Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies

3.1/5 - (118 votes)

Sweet, buttery, and dough, meet this new dairy-free and egg-free take on our classic sugar cookie.

Learn more