Our gourmet cookie flavors
Cookie gifts available for online ordering and nationwide delivery!
Since 1979, Carol’s Cookies has baked every batch by hand — no shortcuts, no preservatives, just pure, simple ingredients like real butter and farm-fresh eggs. What started in Carol’s home kitchen has grown into a family-run bakery that still makes cookies the old-fashioned way: in small batches, with big flavor. Whether you’re sending a thank-you, celebrating a milestone, or simply craving something sweet, there’s a Carol’s Cookie flavor waiting to make your day a little brighter.
Pumpkin Milk Chocolate
Real pumpkin and warm spice meet pools of creamy milk chocolate in a soft, sweater-weather cookie.
Learn more
Cranberry Orange Chocolate
Tart cranberries and fresh orange zest in a buttery cookie that’s equal parts festive and refreshing.
Learn more
Chai Gingerbread
Cardamom, cinnamon, and clove spice up rich molasses gingerbread, finished with sweet white chocolate. Like a chai latte in cookie form.
Learn more
Birthday Cake
Rich white chocolate and deep notes of vanilla help to make this Birthday Cake Cookie the ultimate everyday celebratory treat!
Learn more
Blueberry Lemon Chocolate Crunch
Meet your new summer crush: our Blueberry Lemon Chocolate Crunch Cookies!
Learn more
S’mores Cookies
Taste the campfire with our S’mores Cookies. Gooey marshmallows and rich milk chocolate meet in a nostalgic, gourmet treat.
Learn more
Chocolate Chip
A classic favorite: crispy edges, chewy, buttery center, loaded with rich, semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Learn more
Toffee Chocolate Crunch
Ultra rich dark chocolate chips with sinful toffee bits mixed into our classic, buttery dough.
Learn more
Oatmeal Raisin Pecan
There’s nothing more nostalgic than our oatmeal raisin cookies with crunchy pecans. Perfectly chunky texture pushes this decadent treat over the top. One of Carol’s classics!
Learn more
Old-Fashioned Sugar
No homemade sugar cookies can rival the size, texture and taste of our handmade version.
Learn more
Peanut Butter Chocolate Combo
We thought peanut butter cookies couldn’t get any better, then we added chocolate dough. And chocolate chips to top off this perfect cookie combination.
Learn more
Snickerdoodle
Crunchy, cinnamony, chewy snickerdoodle cookies will remind you of fresh apple pie — hold the apple — with extra sugar on top!
Learn more
Kitchen Sink
When you can’t decide, go with the cookie that has everything but the kitchen sink: nuts, chocolates, oats, coconut, and more.
Learn more
Chocolate Chip with Walnuts
Go crazy. Go wild. Go Chocolate Chip Cookies with nuts. Our classic chocolate chip cookie with extra crunch from California walnuts.
Learn more
Oatmeal Chocolate Cherry
Dark chocolate. Cherry. Oatmeal. Cookies. Four things that are not normally together in a cookie but really should be.
Learn more
Double Chocolate Brownie
We took our chocolate dough, added more chocolate, and made a masterpiece of a brownie-like cookie. Get the milk ready.
Learn more
Milk Chocolate Chunk
This extreme twist on a classic mixes the biggest cookie with the biggest chunks of milk chocolate.
Learn more
Toffee Fudge Brownie
This caramelly, fudge-filled cookie was created when we combined our other incredible chocolate cookies. It lives up to the legacy.
Learn more
Plant-Based Chocolate Chip
Our classic chocolate chip cookie without dairy and eggs, but with all the same flavor and deliciousness.
Learn more
Plant-Based Old-Fashioned Sugar
Sweet, buttery, and dough, meet this new dairy-free and egg-free take on our classic sugar cookie.
Learn more
Coffee Caramel Cookies
Our new Coffee Caramel Cookies contains natural espresso and coffee with rich milk chocolate and sweet toffee pieces that is the perfect pick-me-up for any time of the day.
Learn more
Oatmeal Raisin
Conjure up childhood memories of grandma’s kitchen with our small-batch, mini Oatmeal Raisin Cookies.
Learn more